How Much Do Insurance Rates Increase Following an Accident?


Each insurance company uses an individual methodology that affects the formation of the insurance price. However, the driving experience is important for most of them, namely the presence/absence of accidents in the client’s history. This is one of those criteria that can significantly increase the cost of the policy. It all depends on the details of the situation and the insurance company’s conditions.

For example, some organizations suggest favorable offers that help avoid rate hikes or at least get a discount. One of these solutions is accident forgiveness insurance, which helps to curb rate hikes. We suggest that you learn more about this service and determine how much the tariff may increase after an accident.

How Does an Emergency Affect the Amount of Insurance Rates?

The amount by which the contribution increases depends directly on the type of consequences of the road accident. According to Forbes Advisor, the indicators increase by 47% in the case of identifying injuries to participants and by 45% if only material damage is detected. These are averages that may vary by state and insurance company. As suggested by carinsurancecheap, car insurance accident forgiveness is also important.

If such an offer is available, the increase may be insignificant or non-existent. Otherwise, the difference can be big. Consider the average tariffs in the USA.

Tariff type One at-fault accident Without emergencies
Minimal coverage 860-670 $ 560-570 $
Full coverage 2400-2500 $ 1600-1700 $

Moreover, the indicators increase, even in the case of a minor accident, in which there were no serious consequences. For insurance companies, this is already a certain risk. If we consider the indicators in more detail, we can draw several conclusions. Rates for drivers who cause accidents go up by at least 50%. Such values were observed in insurance companies in almost every state.

On average, guilty car owners started paying $830 more per year than drivers who did not break the rules. Separately, it is worth considering the situation in Texas, Louisiana, Florida, and California. The average rate for drivers involved in accidents has increased by $1,200 per year in these states.

Under such conditions, the question of how to save money on car insurance becomes relevant. After all, unexpected situations can happen on the road, which sometimes does not depend on the will of the driver. Moreover, tariffs will rise almost as much as in the case of an at-fault accident. In this case, car insurance with accident forgiveness is important. This is one of the effective ways to reduce the impact of emergencies on the formation of the policy price.

Do Rates Increase for Drivers Who Are Not at Fault in Road Accidents?


As a general rule, insurance companies raise auto insurance rates for those who cause an accident on the road. That is if guilt is proven in the process and the consequences in the form of injuries and material damage are revealed. In other cases, the rate increase usually does not occur. It is possible to distinguish the following situations among them:

  • Hitting a car by another vehicle: If you did not violate traffic rules and at the same time you were hit by another vehicle, then there is no fault. Therefore, car insurance rates will not increase.
  • At the time of the damage, your car was properly parked: Since the circumstances that created the emergency were not your fault, you are not guilty. For insurance companies, this is not a reason to increase rates.

In any situation, insurance companies will expect confirmation that the accident was not your fault. This fact can be confirmed by providing the necessary documents. This can be a written statement from the other driver confirming guilt, a statement from the other driver’s insurance company confirming the admission of guilt, or a report from law enforcement agencies about the accident. This all gives the insurance company an understanding of when the accident forgiveness is worth it and to leave the rates at the same level.

Why Do Auto Insurance Rates Go Up After Accidents?

All insurance companies use statistical data in the process of forming the value of their products. Some of them indicate that the probability of getting into an accident increases if the driver has already become a participant in it. This is not a certain type of punishment, as it may seem to some drivers, but a proportional increase in size.

It is easy to explain – the risk of cost increases for insurance companies. That is why they are starting to raise rates on auto insurance with accidents. If guilt is not proven, then you can count on minimal financial consequences. In any case, the occurrence is recorded in the database. However, such data are stored for only a few years. After this period, the rates may decrease again.

Can Auto Insurance Rate Hikes Be Prevented After an Accident?


It is possible to keep rates at the level that existed before the occurrence of an emergency only in the case of accident forgiveness auto insurance. This service is given under different conditions. Companies can provide it as additional coverage, in an automatic mode or a combined solution. In the first case, you will have to pay a separate fee for use.

The second option involves using it free of charge, and in the third case, the offer includes a combination of an automatic and a paid solution. Drivers who want to learn more about how accident forgiveness works should consider additional aspects. Among them, you can highlight:

  • Entering information about the accident in the driver’s file: Even if it is an accident or an emergency that was not your fault, insurance companies add information to the electronic database. Other organizations working in this field can see this information. This means that in the case of a change of company, the tariffs may increase.
  • Upgraded accident forgiveness: Service providers may occasionally make changes to their products. That is why you need to periodically check the offers to be able to choose the best solution for yourself. In addition, you need to be interested in changes in the current auto insurance.
  • The existence of certain restrictions on the forgiveness of accidents: In the USA, not all insurance companies offer such a service. In addition, auto insurance accident forgiveness is prohibited in some states. In particular, such rules apply in the state of California.

In addition, this type of insurance may include additional restrictions. For example, some policies specify that forgiveness is applied only once. This applies to all drivers whose insurance is covered by the document. That is, under the policy, forgiveness is carried out only concerning one accident. In some insurance companies, another scheme may also apply. For example, forgiveness can be made after 3 years of accident-free driving.



Accidents are one of the main factors increasing car insurance rates. Even one minor event can lead to a rate increase of almost 2 times. This cost will apply in case of renewal of the product or purchase of a new policy. In some situations, such increases can be avoided. It can be an accident or an accident caused by the fault of another driver. In addition, you can use auto insurance accident forgiveness.

Written by Kan Dail